Injunction doubts as Giggs named

2011-05-24 12:46:25

24 May 2011 Last updated at 13:24 Share this page Delicious Digg Facebook reddit StumbleUpon Twitter Email Print Injunctions doubt as footballer Ryan Giggs named by MP The injunction had blocked the disclosure of details about the alleged affair Continue reading the main story Related Stories Profile: John Hemming UK rights law 'may need amending' Breaking super-injunctions

The future use of injunctions could be in doubt after the naming in Parliament of a footballer who tried to use one to hide an alleged affair.

Lib Dem MP John Hemming named Manchester United star Ryan Giggs in a Commons question on privacy orders.

The prime minister has called for a review into the use of injunctions, calling it "unsustainable".

BBC legal affairs correspondent Clive Coleman said the system was now looking "weak and fractured".

Using parliamentary privilege to break the court order, Mr Hemming said it would not be practical to imprison the 75,000 Twitter users who had named the player.

The High Court rejected two attempts on Monday to overturn the ban, the first after a Scottish paper named the footballer on Sunday, and the second after Mr Hemming's action.

Media lawyers think it is likely that the publishers of the Sun newspaper will try to get it lifted again on Tuesday.

'Law not working'

The player obtained the order against ex-Big Brother contestant Imogen Thomas, who is a former Miss Wales, and the Sun.

The footballer's lawyers have also obtained a High Court order asking Twitter to reveal details of users who had revealed his identity after thousands named him.

Continue reading the main story Analysis Clive Coleman Legal correspondent, BBC News

There now seems to be a recipe for melting court injunctions.

The ingredients? Press speculation about the order; publication online through social networking sites; and the intervention of a member of parliament using the protection of parliamentary privilege.

Celebrities and public figures will be far less prepared to apply for injunctions.

And lawyers will have to caution their clients heavily about the very significant risks involved.

If the injunction system is ineffective, the government will have to find an alternative. They are bound under the European Convention on Human Rights to protect the right to private and family life.

If they cannot find a way of doing that, it is inevitable that cases will be taken to the European Court of Human Rights by people complaining the government have failed to protect their right to privacy.

The privacy battle between judges and MPs

The Attorney General Dominic Grieve has updated the Cabinet following the announcement of joint committee of peers and MPs to investigate the use of privacy orders.

The Prime Minister's official spokesman said David Cameron had described what was happening as unsustainable, with privacy law evolving through judgements and information circulating on the internet.

He said the committee had been established at it was a complicated issue and required serious thought.

Our correspondent said if no solution could be found there could be a stream of cases going to the European Court of Human Rights complaining that the government had failed to protect their right to privacy.

Conservative MP John Whittingdale who will chair the committee on privacy, said ministers needed to act quickly.

"The internet is already distributing names of people who have injunctions on a daily basis. The law is clearly not working. And that's not a situation we can allowed to continue for long," he said.

Parliamentary privilege protects MPs and peers from prosecution for statements made in the House of Commons or House of Lords.

Addressing MPs on Monday, Mr Hemming said: "Mr Speaker, with about 75,000 people having named Ryan Giggs it is obviously impracticable to imprison them all."

House of Commons speaker John Bercow interrupted the MP saying: "Let me just say to the honourable gentleman, I know he's already done it, but occasions such as this are occasions for raising the issues of principle involved, not seeking to flout for whatever purpose."

Twitter threat

John Hemming later told the BBC why he had named Mr Giggs.

"Basically when he... showed that he was going to go after relatively normal people and try and prosecute them, for gossiping about him on a matter of trivia, I think he has to be held to account for that," he said.

Please turn on JavaScript. Media requires JavaScript to play.

//

Source: